+44 7393 450837
Follow on

What is a Smart Beta ETF

Are you also asking the question “What is a Smart Beta ETF?”

Many investors are looking to smart beta ETFs as an alternative to passive index funds and actively managed mutual funds in order to diversify their portfolios and boost their chances of beating the market.

What is a Smart Beta ETF? How do Smart Beta ETFs work? What are the benefits and risks of Smart Beta ETFs?

This article will provide responses to all of these questions as well as a few others. 

If you want to invest as an expat or high-net-worth individual, you can email me (advice@adamfayed.com) or use these contact options.

What is Traditional ETF

An exchange-traded fund, sometimes known as an ETF, is a type of pooled investment instrument that operates very similarly to a mutual fund. ETFs, in general, have a tendency to replicate the performance of a certain index, sector, commodity, or other asset type.

This is true whether the ETF is investing in stocks, bonds, or commodities. However, ETFs, in contrast to mutual funds, have the distinct quality of being transferable on a stock market, in the same manner as actual stocks; this enables investors to buy or sell ETFs.

Starlord - What is a Smart Beta ETF
Chart and pen

ETFs have the flexibility to adopt various structures in order to monitor a wide range of assets, ranging from the value of a single commodity to an enormous and heterogeneous array of securities.

This range of assets allows ETFs to monitor a wide variety of assets, including the value of a wide variety of assets.

ETFs are able to be structured in a way that enables them to duplicate and track a variety of different investment strategies because of their organizational capabilities.

The SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY) was the first exchange-traded fund to be made available to investors.

Its purpose was to replicate the results of the S&P 500 Index. This particular ETF is still actively traded in the present day.

How Do Traditional ETFs work

An ETF derives its name from the fact that it is traded on an exchange, similar to the manner in which stocks are traded.

The value of an ETF’s shares is subject to fluctuations during the trading day due to market transactions including the buying and selling of these shares.

In contrast to mutual funds, which are not subject to exchange trading and are only traded once daily following market closure.

Moreover, ETFs exhibit a greater degree of cost efficiency and liquidity in comparison to mutual funds.

An ETF is a financial instrument that encompasses a diversified portfolio of underlying assets, in contrast to the one-asset focus of stocks.

Due to the presence of many assets inside an ETF, these investment vehicles are often favoured by investors seeking diversification.

ETFs have the capacity to encompass a diverse range of investment options, such as equities, commodities, fixed-income securities, or a combination thereof.

ETFs have the capacity to possess a diverse portfolio consisting of numerous equities spanning across various industries, or alternatively, they can be focused on a certain industry or sector.

Certain investment funds concentrate exclusively on U.S. securities, but others have a broader international perspective.

As an illustration, ETFs with a focus on banking might comprise a selection of stocks from diverse banks within the industry. Click here if you are interested in private banking.

An ETF is a financial instrument that possesses marketability, denoting its capacity to be readily purchased and sold on several exchanges during trading hours.

Additionally, ETFs can be subject to short selling. In the United States, the majority of ETFs are structured as open-ended funds and are governed by the Investment Company Act of 1940, unless specific regulations have subsequently altered their regulatory obligations.

Open-end funds do not impose restrictions on the number of investors participating in the investment vehicle.

Pros and Cons of Traditional ETFs

One of the advantages of traditional ETFs is that they offer a more cost-effective investment option as compared to purchasing individual stocks housed within an ETF portfolio.

Investors are required to do a single transaction for purchase and another for sale, resulting in a reduction in broker commissions due to the limited number of trades conducted by investors.

In general, brokers commonly impose a commission fee for every transaction conducted. Certain brokers also provide the option of engaging in no-commission trading for specific low-cost ETFs, thereby significantly diminishing expenses for investors.

The expense ratio of an ETF refers to the expenses incurred in the operation and management of the fund. ETFs generally exhibit reduced expenditures due to their practice of tracking an index.

As an illustration, in the case of an ETF that replicates the S&P 500 Index, it might encompass the entire spectrum of 500 equities comprising the S&P, thus constituting a passively managed investment vehicle that requires comparatively less time and effort.

Traditional ETFs also have disadvantages. Not all ETFs adhere to a passive approach of tracking an index, which might result in a comparatively higher expense ratio.

What is a Smart Beta ETF

A smart Beta ETF refers to an ETF that employs a systematic approach in picking investments for inclusion in its portfolio.

An ETF is a financial instrument that is designed to replicate the performance of a specific index, such as the S&P 500.

What is smart beta? Smart beta ETFs leverage conventional ETFs as a foundation while customizing the constituents of the fund’s portfolio according to pre-established financial metrics.

The regulations dictating the composition of ETFs are contingent upon the guidelines established during the fund’s establishment.

Additionally, it is worth noting that a fund may assign varying weightings to certain stocks within its portfolio.

Weighting refers to the practice of allocating a greater proportion of a fund’s holdings to one particular stock compared to another, based on a fundamental factor such as the stock’s value.

Certain ETFs have the capacity to replicate the performance of specific stock indices, which may exclusively comprise bank stocks, huge corporations, or technology stocks.

The market capitalization weighting approach is often employed to determine the number of shares from a company’s stock that constitute an index or fund.

A market capitalization weighting strategy involves the selection of companies based on their market capitalization, which is determined by multiplying the share price by the number of outstanding shares.

A corporation with a substantial number of outstanding shares, along with a considerable increase in its stock value, will possess a notable representation within a market capitalization index.

Smart Beta utilizes a non-conventional approach in contrast to the commonly employed cap-weighted index technique.

However, it considers detailed elements that are unique to a single company or industry. A smart Beta ETF may opt to select firms that exclusively demonstrate specific behaviours or criteria.

The measures encompass many criteria such as earnings growth, stock momentum (i.e., the magnitude of upward or downward movement), and profitability.

Every ETF is governed by a set of regulations that form an integral component of a comprehensive systematic methodology for selecting equities to be incorporated within the fund.

How Do Smart Beta ETFs Work

The term “smart beta” is used to describe a group of investment methods that reject the use of market capitalisation in index development.

The focus of smart beta is on the transparent and rule-based capture of investing characteristics or market inefficiencies.

Smart beta’s rising popularity can be attributed to investors’ pursuit of risk minimization, diversification across multiple factors, and an increase in risk-adjusted returns in excess of cap-weighted indexes.

To passively track indices, smart beta approaches take into account factors other than traditional market cap, such as volatility, liquidity, quality, value, size, and momentum.

This is due to the fact that smart beta strategies follow the same index rules and transparency standards as traditional index strategies.

Instead of following broad market benchmarks like the S&P 500 or the Nasdaq 100 Index, these funds zero in on specific market segments where profits can be made.

Benefits of Smart Beta ETFs

Several smart Beta ETFs have been specifically formulated to enhance portfolio returns, optimize dividend yields, and mitigate portfolio risks.

One potential advantage of Smart Beta techniques is the utilization of equally weighted indexing, as some proponents may contend.

This parameter reduces the significance placed on stocks within the index that have the highest market capitalization weightings.

Starlord - What is a Smart Beta ETF
Chart and pen

In the context of market-cap weightings, it is observed that the underperformance of the largest companies or holdings can significantly influence the performance of the index in comparison to the relatively smaller components of the index.

Smart beta differs from standard market capitalization-weighted index funds in that it is not considered a passive strategy.

Although Smart Beta ETFs often have higher expense ratios compared to passive index products, they remain more cost-effective than the majority of actively managed funds.

Smart Beta ETFs are a suitable investment option for individuals seeking to optimize their income and returns, while concurrently providing the opportunity to mitigate risk.

Risks of Smart Beta ETFs

Smart Beta ETFs are a nascent investment strategy that may demonstrate limited trading activity. Insufficient trading volume or liquidity may lead to challenges for investors in promptly selling or divesting their positions.

The expenses associated with readjusting the initial index weighting can be substantial. The rise in price can be attributed to the acquisition of equities by the fund from the index that is slated for inclusion in the fund.

Consequently, the fees associated with smart Beta strategies may exhibit a comparatively smaller magnitude in comparison to actively managed funds, albeit the potential cost reduction may not be of substantial significance.

Smart Beta ETFs have the potential to exhibit inferior performance compared to conventional indexes, such as the S&P 500, due to the necessity of frequent readjustments to align with these indexes.

In essence, the inclusion and divestment of assets are determined in accordance with the regulations governing the fund.

Trading Smart Beta ETFs can present greater challenges compared to trading regular indexes due to the multitude of variables that need to be taken into account.

Consequently, the prices of Smart Beta ETFs may exhibit deviations from the intrinsic value of the underlying fund.

Types of Smart Beta ETFs

A dividend growth rate could be used in the screening process for a Smart Beta ETF’s holdings. Investors are rewarded for their loyalty to a firm by receiving a portion of its profits in the form of dividends. Dividends are typically only paid by large, stable, and successful firms.

The predicted volatility of equities is factored into risk-weighted techniques. Funds may restrict holdings to low-volatility stocks in an effort to limit overall portfolio risk.

Volatility is a measure of the degree to which the price of a security rises and falls. On the other hand, other investors may seek high-growth firms and a fund that specializes in them.

Though numerous variations of Smart Beta ETF strategies exist, some of the most widespread are as follows:

  • This approach does not use stock price or market capitalization to determine how much weight to give to individual holdings or the overall fund.
  • Financially driven fundamentals and indicators are used in the selection and weighting of companies in a fundamentally weighted index.
  • Factor-based investing assigns greater importance to stocks that meet certain criteria, such as those with strong balance sheets, cheap valuations, or rapid revenue growth.
  • This strategy favours companies and indices that have experienced modest price changes over a certain time frame, or low volatility.

Smart Beta ETF Management Styles

Smart Beta ETFs employ a hybrid investment approach that combines elements of both passive and active strategies.

Smart Beta ETF Active Management

Active investing can be likened to the practice of entrusting an investment manager with the responsibility of selecting specific equities to be included within a portfolio.

An actively managed fund engages in the buying and selling of stocks in accordance with certain basic indicators, such as earnings or financial ratios, as deemed necessary.

Smart Beta ETF Passive Management

Passive funds are characterized by their adherence to tracking an index, hence eliminating the involvement of an investment manager in the selection of stocks.

Passive funds generally exhibit lower fees as a consequence. For instance, a financial fund may opt to replicate the performance of the S&P 500 by closely monitoring and emulating the movements of each individual stock inside the index.

Smart Beta is an investment strategy that combines elements of both active and passive investing. The approach employed is characterized by the utilization of an index, hence imbuing it with a passive nature.

However, it also takes into account alternative criteria when selecting stocks or investments from the aforementioned index.

To clarify, a Smart Beta Fund designed to replicate the performance of the S&P 500 index would not include all constituent stocks in the index.

Alternatively, it could want to exclusively choose those that demonstrate a particular behaviour, such as a predetermined % increase in income.

What is a Smart Beta ETF Strategy

The development of a smart beta investment strategy does not adhere to a singular approach, as the objectives of investors can vary depending on their individual requirements.

However, several managers adopt a prescriptive approach in establishing smart beta concepts that are both value-generating and aligned with economic intuition.

Starlord - What is a Smart Beta ETF
Chart and pen

Equity smart beta strategies aim to mitigate the inefficiencies that arise from market-capitalization-weighted benchmarks.

Funds have the option to adopt a thematic strategy in order to effectively manage this risk. This involves directing attention towards the mispricing that arises due to investors’ pursuit of short-term gains, as an illustrative example.

Managers may opt to establish or adhere to an index that assigns weights to investments based on fundamental factors, such as earnings or book value, as opposed to market capitalization.

In an alternative method, managers may opt for a risk-weighted strategy in the context of smart beta, wherein they construct an index by making assumptions about future volatility.

For instance, this may entail conducting an examination of past performance and assessing the relationship between the level of risk associated with an investment and the corresponding return it generates.

The manager needs to assess the extent to which they are willing to incorporate assumptions into the index. They can adopt a method for constructing the index that involves assuming various combinations of correlations.

Final Thoughts

Smart beta ETFs are a new and exciting way to invest passively. They give buyers a unique mix of active strategy elements in a passive vehicle.

These ETFs try to do better than standard market-cap-weighted indices by using things like value, size, momentum, and quality.

They also keep the benefits of low fees and being clear. A lot of people are interested in smart beta strategies because they can give buyers better risk-adjusted returns and a more personalized way to reach their financial goals.

As investments change, smart beta ETFs are a useful tool for people who want to spread out their holdings and take advantage of different sources of alpha in a market that is always shifting.

Pained by financial indecision? Want to invest with Adam?

smile beige jacket 4 1024x604 1

Adam is an internationally recognised author on financial matters, with over 760.2 million answer views on Quora.com, a widely sold book on Amazon, and a contributor on Forbes.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This website is not designed for American resident readers, or for people from any country where buying investments or distributing such information is illegal. This website is not a solicitation to invest, nor tax, legal, financial or investment advice. We only deal with investors who are expats or high-net-worth/self-certified  individuals, on a non-solicitation basis. Not for the retail market.



Gain free access to Adam’s two expat books.

Gain free access to Adam’s two expat books.

Get more strategies every week on how to be more productive with your finances.